Site Information

 Loading... Please wait...

Amish Fry Pie Sampler


A pie you can hold in your hand, our delicious Amish fry pies are similar to a turnover or Amish half-moon pies. Made with our own pie filling and homemade dough, the pastries are fried then sealed with a sweet vanilla-flavored glaze. Each pie is 5 oz (larger than many commercial fry pies). A great gift idea!

*For maximum enjoyment, we recommend eating these within 3 days of receipt. Keep refrigerated. They may be frozen for up to 4 months if desired.*

One dozen assorted fry pies - two each of the following flavors:

  • Apple
  • Cherry
  • Blackberry
  • Blueberry
  • Peach
  • Strawberry

*Please note we ship Monday through Friday (closed Saturday & Sunday). FedEx Picks Up by 1:00 pm Eastern Time.

Shipping Map from Sugarcreek, OH:

Gift Wrapping:
Options available

Product Reviews

Write Review

Showing reviews 1-10 of 14 | Next

  1. Decadence at last...... 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 10th Sep 2020

    These pies are heart-pounding decadence. Every pie is bulging with fruity centers. High quality glaze and a buttery outside crust is like a fine cookie. Its almost like two reads in one. Don't pass on these. Live a little and try the sampler NOW!!!
    PS A note is included telling you fir three days in the refrigerator the pies are good. However if you freeze them they last for 4 months

  2. MMMMM-PIE!! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 13th Jan 2020

    Pa. to Ia. Passing through Ohio and stopped at a gas/mart about 4:30 a.m. Got coffee and a Dutchman Peach Pie....YUM!! We both exclaimed...If we hadn't already traveled about 15 miles we would have gone back and loaded up!! Kept label ordered more pies online......AND Butter Cheese and chicken breasts.....ALL are GREAT....That cheese makes everything taste better!

  3. Fry Pies 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 23rd Jul 2019

    Searched all over Dayton looking for the fry pies - glad we found these on the website. They were great...fruit was fresh. Totally impressed with your service. Thank you

  4. Fry Pie Love 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 31st Aug 2018

    I love the fry pies. My son had a Pig Roast Wedding reception this weekend. Way to hot out for cake. The fry pies were a huge hit. I walked past one elderly guest sitting with his cane and 2 pies in front of him. "nice choice", I said. His eyes twinkled and he was smiling with such joy. These are my favorite thing from Dutch Valley, he told me. I cannot make the trip there anymore and am so thrilled to have these. He thanked me for driving down to get them. He was beyond thrilled when I told him that they were shopped to my door. He was so excited. I was walking away as he was calling for his wife--he needed to place an order ! You made him so very happy and I will never forget it either. I did leave them packaged as they came and filled a basket. Pie love.

  5. very good but limited shelf life 3 Star Review

    Posted by on 18th Apr 2018

    These pies were good however they were inedible the 3rd day we had them. It is disappointing to not be able to even try all the product. They were a soggy mush by day 3. I realize they are a fresh product but to not enjoy half the products seems like a waste for the cost. I have ordered similar products before and at least gotten 5 days. If you can consume 12 pies day 1 or 2, would recommend.

  6. Amish Pies are DA Best in US 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 6th Feb 2018

    I have been ordering for years since I can't them here in St.Louis. They package them so they come in perfect condition. Great for holidays or when you have the taste for a great fried pie. Personnel are kind and value their customers as well.

  7. good! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 2nd Jan 2018

    Shipped all the way to Alaska, and they were excellent! Thanks!

  8. Not too good 2 Star Review

    Posted by on 18th Oct 2017

    I ordered 12 of the fry pies. When they arrived, they were crushed and smashed. They appeared not to have been cooked long enough, and the packaging allowed for them to move around in the box, causing them to arrive in the condition they did. I put six of the pies in the freezer, the other six I placed on a cookie sheet and baked them for about 30 minutes more. That seemed to help a little, but they were still smashed. On the plus side, the filling is very tasty, but I don't think I'll be ordering them again.

  9. Addicting! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 4th Sep 2017

    I love fried pies. Being from the south, it was something I grew up eating. It's real hard to find homemade fried pies anymore, and I haven't had a store-bought fried pie that I liked. I did an Internet search recently and found Dutchman. I purchased the sampler and haven't eaten one that haven't loved. If I could change one thing about ordering Dutchman pies online, it would be to have the option of creating my own sampler.

  10. FRY PIE REVIEW 3 Star Review

    Posted by on 29th Dec 2016

    I received my 12 fry pies that I ordered and was so anxious to receive for Christmas Eve dinner. I was somewhat disappointed because the crust was so soggy and tough compared to the ones I purchased when in Amish country in the fall. Also, my niece loves raisen pie, one was labeled raisen but was really blueberry. I don't think I would order them again. I really love good fry pies.

Showing reviews 1-10 of 14 | Next

Find Similar Products by Category