Site Information

 Loading... Please wait...

Amish Long Johns or Creamsticks


One of the most popular items in our bakeries, our Amish creamsticks (also known as eclairs or long johns) are a rich decadent treat. At approximately seven inches long, our homemade creamsticks will dwarf most commercial bakeries' pastries. The creamsticks (and all our bakery pastries) are fried in trans-fat free soybean oil then filled liberally with our light, fluffy bavarian cream. Baked and shipped from Ohio's Amish Country.

Each cream stick is individually wrapped and un-iced for easier transit (can freeze for later if desired). Your choice of frosting - packaged separately.

*Please note we ship Monday through Friday (closed Saturday & Sunday). FedEx Picks Up by 1:00 pm Eastern Time.

Shipping Map from Sugarcreek, OH:

Gift Wrapping:
Options available

Product Reviews

Write Review

Showing reviews 1-10 of 20 | Next

  1. Just like I remember as a kid 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 6th May 2020

    Since moving to South Carolina thirteen years ago, I have not been able to find "cream sticks" (as we called them). As a child growing up in Massillon, Ohio, I remember stopping at the bakery after church to purchase a dozen and being allowed to devour one cream stick on my home. Then, I saw an advertisment for "Amish Long Johns" and . . . WOW! . . . I was a kid again!!!

  2. yummy 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 21st Oct 2019

    loved them

  3. Best Long John Cream stick ever 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 5th Sep 2019

    Out of this world. I will buy again

  4. Shipping Issue 3 Star Review

    Posted by on 7th Aug 2019

    I had these delivered to Florida as a gift. They were shipped on a Wednesday for Saturday delivery and were no longer cool once they arrived. I'm not certain if the filling is dairy based but if so, overnight delivery should be recommended.

  5. Fresh cream sticks delivered to Georgia. 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 9th May 2019

    Recipients said the cream sticks were so fresh. They loved them.

  6. Amazing! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 20th Feb 2019

    They arrived fresh and were as delicious as the ones I had when I had when at the restaurant.

  7. Amazingly fresh! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 18th Feb 2019

    First of all, the long johns were very LONG, not your average donut. They were generously filled with cream and an ample supply of icing was provided. They stayed fresh for 3 days (yes, we managed not to eat them all on day one!) and we enjoyed every bite.

  8. Bakery Products 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 27th Dec 2018

    I ordered the cream sticks, pecan rolls, cinnamon rolls, and Trail Bologna and Swiss Cheese. I would give everything 5 stars as they are all exceptional products. My biggest compliment was the care in shipping. It was meticulous! Everything was still so fresh and in perfect condition. I couldn't recommend it any higher. It was shipped from Ohio to Seattle, Wa.
    Thank you again. Sincerely, Alan Wiley

  9. Satisfied a Craving 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 4th Apr 2018

    These cremesticks are really big! Had I known I wouldn't have ordered two dozen. I put a dozen and a half in the freezer so I'm hoping they will still be good when I need a fix. But these truly did satisfy my craving for something I can't find in my state.

  10. Tasty 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 5th Feb 2018

    Very good cream sticks. They supply you with your very own frosting! Love love love it!

Showing reviews 1-10 of 20 | Next

Find Similar Products by Category