Site Information

 Loading... Please wait...

Amish Pumpkin Pie


It's not your typical pumpkin pie! Traditional pumpkin pie is heavy with a strong pumpkin taste. With our pie, enjoy the lighter, milder custard-style pumpkin pie that has been a mainstay in our restaurants and bakeries for years.

Pies will arrive pre-baked and frozen in an insulated shipping cooler. Simply thaw in the oven and your home will be filled with the sweet scent of our Amish bakery. Instructions are included. Baked and shipped from Ohio's Amish Country.

9 inch diameter pie. Whipped cream not included.

*Please note we ship Monday through Friday (closed Saturday & Sunday). FedEx Picks Up by 1:00 pm Eastern Time.

Shipping Map from Sugarcreek, OH:

Gift Wrapping:
Options available

Product Reviews

Write Review

  1. Excellent Pie 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 17th Dec 2020

    easy to order
    Prompt delivery
    quality packaging
    Excellent, tasty pie

  2. Taste of home 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 20th Nov 2020

    I purchased this for my sister's birthday and she was thrilled to find a favorite from home at her doorstep. Dutchman hospitality was wonderful at helping me make this surprise happen. Thank you.

Find Similar Products by Category