Site Information

 Loading... Please wait...

Buttermilk Cookies


Possibly our all-time most popular cookie, these tender buttermilk cookies are topped with smooth homemade brown sugar icing for a decadent treat. Each cookie is approximately 3 in diameter. Individually wrapped.

New! Ask for your cookies to be shipped on a reusable serving tray for easy serving at parties and get-togethers. Trays come with an extra half-dozen cookies for the price (2 1/2 dozen). Note that cookies on trays are not individually wrapped.

*Please note we ship Monday through Friday (closed Saturday & Sunday). FedEx Picks Up by 1:00 pm Eastern Time.

Shipping Map from Sugarcreek, OH:


Product Reviews

Write Review

Showing reviews 1-10 of 11 | Next

  1. Delicious!!! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 17th Jan 2020

    I ordered these before Christmas and had them shipped. I knew I wouldn't have time to make cookies. These came individually packaged and did not stick to the packaging. I froze them and when I needed them I thawed them out. They were perfect, fresh like they were made that day. Thank you for a real quality product!

  2. Very Satisfied 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 27th Dec 2019

    We have always traveled to Holmes Co. for our vacations and brought buttermilk cookies home . Now we can no longer travel and missed them sooo much, so we decided to order them. The cookies were excellent as we remembered and shipping was first class. Everything came in perfect condition and on time. Now when we get homesick for Holmes Co. and the cookies, we will order and know they will be perfect in every way!

  3. Just like being there!!! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 3rd Jun 2019

    My experience in the Dutch valley was amazing! I had to have more of the cookies to remind me of the wonderful time I had.

  4. Very Dissapointed...... 1 Star Review

    Posted by on 27th Jan 2018

    I don't want to sound so negative, but I am glad you want to receive feedback about the products you are sending out. We visit Walnut Creek 3 ties each year, and we are certain to make several visits to Der Dutchman and the bakery. We love the products in the bakery, so I thought it would be a good idea to order some cookies online. It was a huge disappointment. The cookies were stale, despite being individually wrapped. I had to throw them away. It was a total loss and waste of money, and I will never do that again. We will continue to buy your bakery items when we are visiting, however.

    Christy was so nice when she took my order. You should be proud to have her as a member of your team.


  5. best cookies I have ever ate 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 18th Jan 2018

    I crave these cookies. If I could afford them, I would have them every day.

  6. Best cookies in the Nation 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 20th Dec 2017

    Haven't had these cookies for many years but used to be a regular patron of Der Dutchman and always brought them home after a delicious meal!
    These were packed beautifully, and brought back the best of memories. Will be ordering again and again! Thank you for the excellent enjoyment of a long loved product!

  7. Absolutely delicious cookies! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 14th Dec 2017

    I highly recommend trying these cookies. They are absolutely delicious. I will definitely be ordering again! The customer service was excellent as well and items were packaged perfectly.

  8. Awsome 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 27th Nov 2017

    The buttermilk cookies from Dutch Valley were awesome and the mail order service was great.

  9. Old Fashioned Delight! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 13th Feb 2017

    Just like Grandma used to make! Huge cookies are individually packaged and well protected for travel. Wonderful.

  10. the very best 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 17th Jun 2016

    These cookies are the very best things on the face of this Earth ! They're soft, and moist, with incredible frosting.

Showing reviews 1-10 of 11 | Next

Find Similar Products by Category