An old fashioned pie, our butterscotch pie has the the sweet rich taste of brown sugar cooked slowly in a luxurious custard filling. We carefully measure and package each ingredient to make your pie just like the ones we serve in our Der Dutchman Restaurants. No baking is required! Assemble in minutes, according to our included instructions. Prepared and shipped from Ohio's Amish Country.

Contents of the kit:
One 9 inch baked pie crust
Cooked butterscotch filling
Whipped cream

Click to enlarge

Butterscotch Cream Pie Kit

$22.99

7 product reviews

An old fashioned pie, our butterscotch pie has the sweet rich taste of brown sugar cooked slowly in a luxurious custard filling. We carefully measure and package each ingredient to make your pie just like the ones we serve in our Der Dutchman Restaurants. No baking is required! Pies will arrive in an insulated shipping cooler. Assemble in minutes, according to our included instructions. Prepared and shipped from Ohio's Amish Country.

Contents of the kit -

One 9 inch baked pie crust
Cooked butterscotch filling
Whipped cream

*Please note we ship Monday through Friday (closed Saturday & Sunday). FedEx Picks Up by 1:00 pm Eastern Time.

Shipping Map from Sugarcreek, OH: http://www.dutchmanonline.com/shipping-locations/

Gift Wrapping:

Options available

* Pies - Cream Pies:

One Pie
Two Pies

* Want to pre-order? We'll ship out your gift to be received on this date::

Quantity:

Product Reviews

Write Review

Broken pie shell

Posted by Unknown on 28th Apr 2020

The pie was delicious, but when it arrived, the crust was broken into several small pieces.
Yummy =)

Posted by Spring19 on 3rd Jan 2020

This is the best pie ever and the way they shp it is AWESOME!!! THANK YOU =)
BUTTERSCOTCH BLISS

Posted by Patty on 30th Dec 2019

Lived in Midwest for the past 20 years. I've had my share of homemade pies, but this is hands-down, THE BEST BUTTERSCOTCH PIE I tasted ... EVER. Just heavenly. Another thing, thoughtful packaging, and they make shipping dates happen ... no excuses, they just MADE it happen. Bless you; we appreciated that.
awesome butterscotch pie

Posted by Unknown on 28th Nov 2017

Better than moms sorry mom
so delicious and easy!!!

Posted by Unknown on 23rd Nov 2017

It was so simple to prepare the pie. My husband loved it!
Best Butterscotch Pie Ever!

Posted by Godfrey Holzbach on 15th Aug 2017

This is my first order from Dutchman Online and the pie is just as good as I remember from my many trips to the restaurant when I lived in the area. Pie filling, pie crust, and whipped cream all as good as I hoped. Only negative was that one of the whipped cream containers busted open. Will definitely order again and plan or ordering other items too! Pie may become a staple for holidays and birthdays because it is a family favorite!!
Could have been cooled better.

Posted by Grace Graham on 14th Oct 2015

When the pie arrived the cooling packaging was thawed out and the pie filling and whip cream were warm. We were kind of afraid to eat it but we did and were all still alive!!