Site Information

 Loading... Please wait...

Der Dutchman Amish Peanut Butter Spread


Meet your new comfort food. Thick, sweet, and creamy, Amish peanut butter spread is perfect on homemade bread. A Holmes County favorite, this simple snack alternative to peanut butter and jelly is very popular with locals and visitors alike.

Available in 19 oz squeeze bottles.

Gift Wrapping:
Options available

Product Reviews

Write Review

Showing reviews 1-10 of 21 | Next

  1. A Favorite Snack 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 11th Mar 2021

    I fell in love with the "church" peanut butter on a trip to Ohio and Pennsylvania 3 years ago.Now, I ordered it a couple of times a year and have it shipped to Texas. Yes, it is that good.

  2. Great Spread!! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 15th Oct 2020

    I bought the first bottle of this spread in 2018 while on vacation in Ohio. It didn't last long after we got home. Everyone loved it and even mixed it with jelly or spread on bread with bananas for a quick sandwich. It is so very good.

  3. So yummy! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 3rd Aug 2020

    I was so curious about this spread and was not disappointed. It’s yummy. I even tried it the traditional Amish/Mennonite way on a sandwich with cheese, pickles and such. Total surprise! It was DELICIOUS

  4. Amish Peanut Butter 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 2nd Jun 2020

    Positively addictive.

  5. Best Peanut Butter! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 11th Oct 2019

    This is the best tasting Peanut butter I've ever had, You must try some.

  6. amish peanut butter 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 26th Mar 2019

    We love this item and wish the shipping was cheaper because then we could buy more of it!!!!

  7. Brings childhood memories back! 4 Star Review

    Posted by on 12th Mar 2019

    Your taste buds explode when you eat this spread. Takes you back to younger days with "fluff'r'nutter" sandwiches! Absolutely love it on apples! Only negative would be it is hard to get out of container. Cousins from CA fell in love it it also so sent them 3 bottles!!

  8. A must have! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 8th Mar 2019

    Do yourself a favor and do NOT pass on this product! We have tried other Amish products but there has not been anything that has matched the taste and creaminess of this product. The online ordering was easy and the delivery was quick!

  9. must try 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 6th Mar 2018


  10. yummy 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 8th Nov 2017

    Nothing better than Der Dutchman peanut butter.

Showing reviews 1-10 of 21 | Next

Find Similar Products by Category