Site Information

 Loading... Please wait...

Dutchman Christmas Cookie Trays


No time to bake for your holiday party or family gathering? Let our experienced Amish bakers help you! Our homemade cookie trays are assembled, carefully wrapped and ready to serve.

  • Assorted Christmas Cookies – 12 inch tray: 12 Christmas cut-outs, 3 white sugar, 3 peanut butter blossoms, 3 date pinwheels, 3 Russian tea balls, 2 chocolate crinkles, 2 monster cookies and 2 pecan tarts. Also available in all Christmas cut-out cookies.
  • Assorted Christmas Cookies - 16 inch tray: 14 Christmas cut-outs, 4 white sugar, 4 peanut butter blossoms, 4 date pinwheels, 4 Russian tea balls, 4 chocolate crinkles, 4 monster cookies and 4 pecan tarts. Also available in all Christmas cut-out cookies.


*Please note we ship Monday through Friday (closed Saturday & Sunday). FedEx Picks Up by 1:00pm Eastern Time.


*FedEx Home Delivery delivers Tuesday through Saturday.


*FedEx does not deliver on Mondays unless it is a business or shipped by Express (2nd Day or Overnight).




Shipping Map from Sugarcreek, OH:



Product Reviews

Write Review

Showing reviews 1-10 of 49 | Next

  1. Best cookie trays available 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 11th Dec 2019

    We order several Christmas cookie trays every year for friends and associates. They truly rave over the quality. The service is also impeccable and reliable.

  2. So Good I Keep Giving Them as Gifts 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 25th Dec 2018

    Every Christmas I order these cookie trays for two dozen of my business associates and staff members. They love them! I also order some for family members and friends. They all love them too and look forward to receiving them. Quality baked goods at an amazing price makes for a win-win all around. Definitely recommend!

  3. Love your cookie tray! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 20th Dec 2018

    We buy your large cookie tray every year because there is such a beautiful assortment of cookies and they are so delicious! Our family looks forward to it's arrival!!! Thank You!

  4. No Better Gift for Christmas 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 17th Dec 2018

    We order several cookie trays every year for special friends and businesses. We always get enthusiast responses and feedback every recipient. They would dearly miss them if we stopped the tradition!

  5. The Cookie Tray was a True Delight! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 1st Jan 2018

    The cookie tray looked great in the picture. When it arrived my mom and I were truly amazed at the lovely assortment and the detail of the work in the cookies. They also were so good. I knew we'd be busy and christmas cookies are a traditions. These were the best. Highly recommended. Many thanks!!

  6. Cookies are absolutely delicious ,however 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 30th Dec 2017

    This is the second year I have purchased your deluxe cookie trays. The ones I received last year were in perfect condition whenever I received them, however the cookies I received this year were half broken in each of the trays. I was extremely disappointed because I wanted to put them on the buffet. They were so good last year I didn't need to make another dessert at the very last minute.

  7. Wonderfully delicious cookies!! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 28th Dec 2017

    I love the cookies from der Dutchman! You get a wonderful variety, they are fresh, and they arrive when you want them to.

  8. Christmas Cookies 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 27th Dec 2017

    Thank You! Cookies were delicious and had a nice assortment. They also came packaged very well. Was pleasantly surprised since this was the first time getting them delivered. We normally make the trip down. I will definitely do on line with shipping again. Thanks again. One very please and happy customer! Merry Christmas

  9. sugarcreek cookies 4 Star Review

    Posted by on 27th Dec 2017

    A nice assortment of Christmas cookies

  10. Better than Homemade. 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 26th Dec 2017

    I have ordered these cookies before and I am always pleased with my purchase. The variety includes so many favorites and the cookie size on the sugar cookies is very generous. I wish the postage was not so high but I will probably do it again.

Showing reviews 1-10 of 49 | Next

Find Similar Products by Category