Site Information

 Loading... Please wait...

Dutchman Cookie Trays


No time to bake for your party or family gathering? Let our experienced Amish bakers help you! Our homemade cookie trays are assembled, carefully wrapped and ready to serve. You can even freeze them for later use.

Cookies are approximately 3 inches in diameter. Available in assorted trays with the following cookies:

  • chocolate chip
  • molasses
  • snickerdoodle
  • oatmeal
  • peanut butter
  • monster cookies

*Please note we ship Monday through Friday (closed Saturday & Sunday). FedEx Picks Up by 1:00 pm Eastern Time.

Shipping Map from Sugarcreek, OH:

Gift Wrapping:
Options available

Product Reviews

Write Review

  1. A delicious birthday surprise 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 6th Mar 2018

    Sent a mixed cookie tray with shamrock cutouts and others to our daughter for her birthday. She was so surprised that we could order them online. Our family loves the Der Dutchman restaurants and bakery . We live in Ohio and can visit often

  2. always fresh! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 23rd Dec 2017

    These cookies are always fresh and delicious. My mom LOVES them and I make sure to get a tray (or three) for all of us to enjoy.

  3. Great delicious assortment 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 1st Jan 2017

    This was my first purchase for this assortment tray of cookies. Every cookie was moist, soft and delicious. Throughout the delivery process there was not one cookie broken. Will order again next year.

  4. Gifts 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 21st Dec 2016

    These items(2) were purchased as gifts. The recipients were delighted by the quality and variety as well as the packaging.

  5. satisfied 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 28th Jul 2016

    I have always had good results ordering from Dutchman!

  6. Great tray of cookies! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 26th Nov 2015

    Apologize is this is a do-over. Cookie tray was a big hit for our group of ten, and the 3.5 dozen tray was just right. I should not have expected leftovers! They arrived in tip-top shape and were fresh and good.

  7. Cookie tray a hit! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 26th Nov 2015

    Had a small gathering, considered the 2.5 dozen tray but went with the 3.5 thinking leftovers for Thanksgiving, it didn't happen! They went in a flash. Arrived nicely packaged and fresh.

Find Similar Products by Category