Categories
Gift Cards
Meats & Cheeses
Amish Country Meats
Amish Country Cheeses
Steak Sauces and Rubs
Amish Bakery
Amish-style Pies
Breads
Cake
Cookies
Pastries
Sweet Rolls
Pantry
Amish-style Noodles
Butter
Canned Goods
Jams and Spreads
Sarasota Coffee
Snacks
Sweets and Syrups
Amish Gift Baskets
Gifts
Amish Heritage
Backyard & Barbecue
Boutique
Family Fun
Farm & Country
Handmade
Health & Beauty
Home Living
Inspirational
Kitchen & Cooking
New!
Brands
Gifts
Gift Card
Der Dutchman
Amish Wedding Foods
View all brands
Additional Information
Home
About Us
Order & Shipping FAQ
Shipping Locations
Privacy Policy
Contact Us
Facebook
Twitter
Site Information
Loading... Please wait...
Search
1-800-852-2631
On-site Restaurant Orders
My Account
Wish Lists
Sign in
or
Create an account
Categories
Gift Cards
Meats & Cheeses
Amish Country Meats
Amish Country Cheeses
Steak Sauces and Rubs
Amish Bakery
Amish-style Pies
Breads
Cake
Cookies
Pastries
Sweet Rolls
Pantry
Amish-style Noodles
Butter
Canned Goods
Jams and Spreads
Sarasota Coffee
Snacks
Sweets and Syrups
Amish Gift Baskets
Gifts
Amish Heritage
Backyard & Barbecue
Boutique
Family Fun
Farm & Country
Handmade
Health & Beauty
Home Living
Inspirational
Kitchen & Cooking
New!
Home
Pantry
Sweets and Syrups
Sweets and Syrups
Select sub-category
Filter by
Sort by:
Featured Items
Newest Items
Bestselling
Alphabetical: A to Z
Alphabetical: Z to A
Avg. Customer Review
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Hitchers Cat with Lollipop
$7.99
Compare
Add To Cart
Hitchers Donkey with Lollipop
$7.99
Compare
Add To Cart
Hitchers Frog with Lollipop
$7.99
Compare
Add To Cart
Ohio Maple Syrup
$9.99
Compare
Add To Cart