Categories
Gift Cards
Meats & Cheeses
Amish Country Meats
Amish Country Cheeses
Steak Sauces and Rubs
Amish Bakery
Amish-style Pies
Breads
Cake
Cookies
Pastries
Sweet Rolls
Pantry
Amish-style Noodles
Butter
Canned Goods
Fair Trade Coffee
Jams and Spreads
Snacks
Sweets and Syrups
Amish Gift Baskets
Gifts
Lotions
Books and DVDs
Games
Handmade
New!
Brands
Der Dutchman
Amish Wedding Foods
View all brands
Additional Information
Home
About Us
Order & Shipping FAQ
Shipping Locations
Privacy Policy
Contact Us
Facebook
Twitter
Site Information
Loading... Please wait...
Search
1-800-852-2631
On-site Restaurant Orders
My Account
Wish Lists
Sign in
or
Create an account
Categories
Gift Cards
Meats & Cheeses
Amish Country Meats
Amish Country Cheeses
Steak Sauces and Rubs
Amish Bakery
Amish-style Pies
Breads
Cake
Cookies
Pastries
Sweet Rolls
Pantry
Amish-style Noodles
Butter
Canned Goods
Fair Trade Coffee
Jams and Spreads
Snacks
Sweets and Syrups
Amish Gift Baskets
Gifts
Lotions
Books and DVDs
Games
Handmade
New!
Home
Pantry
Sweets and Syrups
Sweets and Syrups
Select sub-category
Filter by
Sort by:
Featured Items
Newest Items
Bestselling
Alphabetical: A to Z
Alphabetical: Z to A
Avg. Customer Review
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Hitchers Cat with Lollipop
$7.99
Compare
Add To Cart
Hitchers Donkey with Lollipop
$7.99
Compare
Add To Cart
Hitchers Frog with Lollipop
$7.99
Compare
Add To Cart
Ohio Maple Syrup
$9.99
Compare
Add To Cart
Loading... Please wait...
Loading... Please wait...
